#Tubestrike 2: This Time We’re Serious

As a broadcast organisation, planning how to cover a major piece of industrial action is never easy. Just when extra people have been placed on shift, bulletins have been altered and the cameras are in place, strikes can be called off at the last minute. The same might apply for the next 24 hour walkout of tube station staff (3/4th October), but in case it doesn’t, we’re preparing for the worst.

As many of you know, BBC London used the new cloud based Ushahidi platform, crowdmap to cover the first in this series of strikes on the 7th September. It was definitely an experiment but we were very happy with how it went. I wrote a blog post with some of my reflections here; in terms of what worked and what we might want to do differently.

We have decided that we would like to use the map again if the strike goes ahead, and our decision is based on one key reason: this is a story that can’t be reported any other way.

While I was excited about using the platform, that came from my passion for social media, and my hope that the experiment would work. It didn’t feel like a journalistic imperative, and some of my colleagues weren’t quite as excited as I was.

But our experience on the day convinced everyone, purely because the BBC’s usual reliance on official sources just could not work in this situation. It was in the Union’s interest to tell the story that stations were closed and that maximum disruption had been achieved. Conversely it was in the interests of Transport for London (TfL) to tell us that as many stations as possible were open.

It wasn’t simply a case of both sides deliberately failing to tell the truth, it was more a case of massaging the truth, and protecting working staff. TfL were moving staff around during the day, opening stations and then closing them just as quickly, trying to keep the locations secret so Union pickets couldn’t be moved around ahead of them.

As a result, as the day progressed it became increasingly clear that we couldn’t rely on the information coming from either side. On crowdmap, during the moderation process, it forces you to define a new report as verified or unverified. At first we were verifying information from the TfL website but we quickly stopped doing that. We found we were posting information but Londoners almost immediately began to dispute those reports via twitter or crowdmap itself.

The point of this post is to ask that people get the word out. The original crowdmap received almost 20,000 unique visitors and obviously we were very happy with that, but we’re also aware that many of those visitors were social media types from all over the world intrigued by the combination of ‘BBC’ ‘crowdsourcing’ and ‘ushahidi’ in a tweet.

Our hope for the proposed strike next week is that the crowdmap becomes a really useful tool for people trying to get to and from work. So we’re asking for a few favours:

  1. Please get the word out – post the map on your blogs, twitter, facebook.
  2. Tell people who live in London they can email us (yourlondon@bbc.co.uk), phone us on 020 7765 1064 or send us an SMS (using 81333 and starting the message LONDON STRIKE).
  3. Show people who might not have seen it, what the map looks like and how they could use it.
  4. Tell us which categories you’d like to see on the map to make it more useful for you.

This isn’t an example of journalists playing with a new tool, or one of those interactive exercises where no-one actually pays as much attention as they should do to the material being submitted. This is our opportunity as Londoners to tell the story of the tubestrike in the only way possible – as a collective force.

The BBC can’t place reporters at every tube station or bus stop, but it can help collate the experiences of millions of Londoners on the 3rd October.

This experiment needs to move out of social media land and into the hands of Londoners to make their commute easier. Its success relies on as many people as possible posting their reports. Let’s see what a real crowdsourcing initiative can look like.

8 thoughts on “#Tubestrike 2: This Time We’re Serious

  1. I’ll have a link back to this post later today and will spread word via Twitter. That said I don’t have too many Londoners following as yet. I suppose you’ll start to see the merits of the crowdmap system being on standby given that these Tube strikes are never a one-off or extremely rare occurrence.

    Shame you can’t get a short TV slot on BBC London local news; a 20-30 second summary would reach many who will be affected and might use the crowdmap. You might want to put in a request for them to broadcast this? Same goes for radio, although to my mind the visuals of the project would more befit a TV broadcast.

    Pete, editor at Dirty Garnet.

  2. Sorry if I’m missing something obvious, but will the map be visible to the public? I guess & hope so, but to save hunting on the day are you able to say where?

  3. Hi Claire,

    I must say I didn’t know about crowdmap at the last tube strike, although I’ve been playing around with an idea on my home bus route that could relate to your point that ” The BBC can’t place reporters at every tube station or bus stop, but it can help collate the experiences of millions of Londoners”

    Not as drastic as millions, but I’ve created a twitter account called “londonbus205″, which I update whenever I am on the bus heading home (I live at the last bus stop) in hope that if it catches on, I can use twitter to get updates on the current movements of Bus 205, specially that the more you move deep into East London, the less teleprompters there is! i.e. whoever is ON the bus can text/email that account of their whereabouts, and I can pretty much guesstimate my waiting time, or just walk, which one sometimes ends up doing anyway just to see the bus whisk by as you reach home :)

    What can be useful to reporters, is that breaking down updates to individual routes, increases the granularity and the more accurate the information/location.

    Nothing beats a live update of someone ON the bus!

  4. I’ll be doing a topic on this strike probably on the 1st or 2nd – so any Londoners who happen by will have it fresh in mind. DG is advertised in the forthcoming issue of Private Eye which should lead to a few Londoners stopping by around that time; mag goes on the sale on the 1st.

    Will do a bit of tweetage to the Londoners I do know…as well as folks who might spread word should they be arsed. Added your website to my links list.

    Pete, editor at Dirty Garnet.

  5. Pingback: [Exclusive] London Underground strike planned for tonight | The Daily Crowdsource - #1 site for crowdsourcing news

  6. Pingback: Tubestrike 4: Crowdmap’s final test « Claire Wardle, PhD

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s